Redeemer Fellowship Church was planted on September 27, 2016 on the campus of the University of Southern Indiana. The church started with five families and a group of USI students, who God used to start a church to reach college students and the Westside of Evansville.

In August 2017, the congregation of Redeemer appointed three elders to pastor the church. Matthew Castro, who led a campus ministry at USI and helped start the church with Joe Hearne, became the pastor of teaching and vision. Denton Ice, who was an alumni of USI, became the pastor of next generation. Sean Melvin became a lay elder. In 2019, Robert Hudson was called and affirmed as the pastor of worship.

We started meeting in our current building on Hogue Rd in December 2017. We were able to purchase the building and property in December 2019 from St. Mark United Church of Christ. Redeemer is located 5 minutes from USI. In December 2021, God called Matthew Castro and his family to serve in ministry in Collierville, TN. Denton Ice became the lead teaching pastor and in February 2022, Aaron Mills was ordained as a lay elder for the church. God continues to use us as a body of believers to reach the city of Evansville and the nations with the gospel of Jesus Christ.